Performing Logistic Regression in R and SAS


My statistics education focused a lot on normal linear least-squares regression, and I was even told by a professor in an introductory statistics class that 95% of statistical consulting can be done with knowledge learned up to and including a course in linear regression.  Unfortunately, that advice has turned out to vastly underestimate the variety and depth of problems that I have encountered in statistical consulting, and the emphasis on linear regression has not paid dividends in my statistics career so far.  Wisdom from veteran statisticians and my own experience combine to suggest that logistic regression is actually much more commonly used in industry than linear regression.  I have already started a series of short lessons on binary classification in my Statistics Lesson of the Day and Machine Learning Lesson of the Day.    In this post, I will show how to perform logistic regression in both R and SAS.  I will discuss how to interpret the results in a later post.

The Data Set

The data set that I will use is slightly modified from Michael Brannick’s web page that explains logistic regression.  I copied and pasted the data from his web page into Excel, modified the data to create a new data set, then saved it as an Excel spreadsheet called heart attack.xlsx.

This data set has 3 variables (I have renamed them for convenience in my R programming).

  1. ha2  – Whether or not a patient had a second heart attack.  If ha2 = 1, then the patient had a second heart attack; otherwise, if ha2 = 0, then the patient did not have a second heart attack.  This is the response variable.
  2. treatment – Whether or not the patient completed an anger control treatment program.
  3. anxiety – A continuous variable that scores the patient’s anxiety level.  A higher score denotes higher anxiety.

Read the rest of this post to get the full scripts and view the full outputs of this logistic regression model in both R and SAS!

R Script for Implementing Logistic Regression

##### Interpreting the Results of a Logistic Regression Model in R
##### By Eric Cai - The Chemical Statistician

# clear all variables in the workspace

heart.attack <- readWorksheet(loadWorkbook("YOUR DIRECTORY PATH HERE/heart attack.xlsx"), sheet = 1)

# perform logistic regression and assign the output object to the variable "logistic.ha"
logistic.ha = glm(ha2 ~ treatment + anxiety, family = binomial, data = heart.attack)

# use the summary() function to view the results of the model

R Output of Logistic Regression Model

Here is the output from summary(logistic.ha).

> summary(logistic.ha)

glm(formula = ha2 ~ treatment + anxiety, family = binomial, data = heart.attack)

Deviance Residuals: 
Min             1Q             Median        3Q          Max 
-2.06190        -0.51429       -0.02087      0.50417     2.11830 

Estimate        Std.           Error       z value      Pr(>|z|) 
(Intercept)     -6.38342       2.50468     -2.549       0.01082 * 
treatment       -2.73309       1.00548     -2.718       0.00656 **
anxiety         0.13970        0.04819     2.899        0.00374 **
Signif. codes: 0 ‘***’    0.001 ‘**’    0.01 ‘*’    0.05 ‘.’    0.1 ‘ ’    1

(Dispersion parameter for binomial family taken to be 1)

Null deviance: 55.452 on 39 degrees of freedom
Residual deviance: 29.753 on 37 degrees of freedom
AIC: 35.753

Number of Fisher Scoring iterations: 5

SAS Script for Implementing Logistic Regression

Here is the SAS script for performing the same logistic regression analysis.  The code at the beginning is useful for clearing the log, the output file and the results viewer.

Useful Options For Every SAS Program 
- With Some Tips Learned From Dr. Jerry Brunner
by Eric Cai - The Chemical Statistician

dm 'cle log; cle out;';
ods html close; 
ods html;

dm 'odsresults; clear';
ods listing close;
ods listing;

          linesize = 105
          formdlim = '-'
          pageno = min;

title 'Worcester Heart Attack Study';

* import the data;
proc import 
          datafile = "INSERT YOUR DIRECTORY PATH HERE\heart attack.xlsx" 
                     dbms = xlsx 
                     out = heart_attack_raw

* create formats for the categorical variables;
proc format;
          value ha      1 = 'Yes'
                         0 = 'No';

          value treatment  1 = 'Yes'
                           0 = 'No';

* add formats and labels to variables in the data set; 
data heart_attack;
           set heart_attack_raw;
           format        ha2 ha.
                         treatment treatment.;
           label         ha2 = '2nd Heart Attack'
                         treatment = 'Received Treatment for Anger'
                         anxiety = 'Anxiety Score';

* export the logistic regression output to a PDF file;
ods graphics on;
ods pdf file = "INSERT YOUR DIRECTORY PATH HERE\SAS output - logistic regression of heart attacks.pdf";

proc logistic
           data = heart_attack;
           class treatment(ref = 'No') / param = ref;
           model ha2(event = 'Yes') = treatment anxiety / parmlabel;

ods pdf close;

SAS Output of Logistic Regression Model

Here is the output as seen in the results viewer.  As you can see in my above code, I also used ods graphics and ods pdf to export the output into a PDF file for easy viewing and reporting.

Worcester Heart Attack Study
The LOGISTIC Procedure
Model Information
Response Variable ha2 2nd Heart Attack
Number of Response Levels 2
Model binary logit
Optimization Technique Fisher’s scoring

Number of Observations Read 40
Number of Observations Used 40

Response Profile
ha2 Total
1 No 20
2 Yes 20
Probability modeled is ha2=’Yes’.

Class Level Information
Class Value Design
treatment No 0
Yes 1

Model Convergence Status
Convergence criterion (GCONV=1E-8) satisfied.

Model Fit Statistics
Criterion Intercept Only Intercept and
AIC 57.452 35.753
SC 59.141 40.820
-2 Log L 55.452 29.753

Testing Global Null Hypothesis: BETA=0
Test Chi-Square DF Pr > ChiSq
Likelihood Ratio 25.6988 2 <.0001
Score 20.3024 2 <.0001
Wald 11.3897 2 0.0034

Type 3 Analysis of Effects
Effect DF Wald
Pr > ChiSq
treatment 1 7.3879 0.0066
anxiety 1 8.4033 0.0037

Analysis of Maximum Likelihood Estimates
Parameter DF Estimate Standard
Pr > ChiSq Label
Intercept 1 -6.3834 2.5048 6.4949 0.0108 Intercept: ha2=No
treatment Yes 1 -2.7331 1.0055 7.3879 0.0066 Received Treatment for Anger Yes
anxiety 1 0.1397 0.0482 8.4033 0.0037 Anxiety Score

Odds Ratio Estimates
Effect Point Estimate 95% Wald
Confidence Limits
treatment Yes vs No 0.065 0.009 0.467
anxiety 1.150 1.046 1.264

Association of Predicted Probabilities and
Observed Responses
Percent Concordant 89.5 Somers’ D 0.823
Percent Discordant 7.3 Gamma 0.850
Percent Tied 3.3 Tau-a 0.422
Pairs 400 c 0.911

3 Responses to Performing Logistic Regression in R and SAS

  1. Rehan says:

    Can you please explain why the coefficients are different?

Your thoughtful comments are much appreciated!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: